THE DESTINATION IS CLEAR; THE JOURNEY STILL NEEDS A PLAN
A Rejoinder to Mr. Dabney Yerima’s “My Reaction to the TPCC”
By
Fontem Neba, PhD
Founding SG of The Consortium
*********
I have read with great interest the _“Independent Opinion”_ of Mr. Dabney Yerima, in which he painstakingly articulates his reservations about the People’s Consultative Conference (TPCC), convened by our elders, and underscores the importance of preserving the quest for an independent Southern Cameroons.
While I may share some of Mr. Yerima’s concerns, I believe there are issues that are far more fundamental to the success of every liberation struggle and which we cannot afford to overlook at this critical juncture in our national journey.
The question before us is not simply whether our people desire an independent homeland. It is also whether we have sufficiently considered the institutional, intellectual, social, psychological and political responsibilities that accompany the pursuit of that aspiration, as well as the challenges that will confront us along the way.
I raised some of these concerns during my maiden engagement with the TPCC conveners and consider it important to bring them into the wider public conversation for the benefit of our people.
My intention is not to diminish Mr. Yerima’s convictions or question his right to express them. Rather, it is to broaden the discussion and draw attention to certain foundational considerations which, in my view, make the People’s Consultative Conference not merely desirable, but indispensable to the future of our liberation struggle. I have previously written extensively on this subject.
Independence and the responsibilities of freedom
Mr. Yerima is emphatic that the destination of our struggle must remain a free and independent Ambazonia. That is a political conviction he is entitled to hold, and one that many Southern Cameroonians share. However, there is an important distinction between knowing where we want to go and adequately preparing for what awaits us when we get there.
Independence is a destination; preparing a people for independence is an undertaking in its own right. A people may be united in their aspiration for freedom without necessarily having considered all the political, institutional, economic and social questions that accompany its attainment.
We cannot wait until we get to Buea before figuring out the issues incidental to liberation and its concomitants. What will become of displaced populations? How will communities fractured by years of conflict be reconciled? What arrangements will facilitate institutional reconstruction, economic recovery and the restoration of public confidence? How will we address the psychological consequences of prolonged violence, bereavement, insecurity and displacement? Are we going to wait for another chaotic phase just to report it as a mistake?
These are not questions for another day. A liberation conference should anticipate and help pre-empt the challenges of freedom, not wait until they become national emergencies.
A conference is not necessarily about choosing a destination
One of the apparent anxieties surrounding TPCC is that consultation might reopen the question of whether Southern Cameroons should pursue independence, federalism or another political arrangement. This interpretation considerably narrows the purpose of a people’s conference.
The first thought that should come to mind when a liberation conference is mentioned should not automatically be the determination of the ultimate political or constitutional arrangement. There are numerous concerns that are common to federalists and independentists alike, and which deserve collective attention irrespective of their preferred political outcome.
The suffering of civilians does not discriminate according to political affiliation. Displacement, disrupted education, economic hardship, insecurity, bereavement, psychological trauma and social fragmentation affect our people collectively. The challenges of reconciliation, institutional rehabilitation, accountability and community recovery are equally common concerns.
Unfortunately, these issues have remained largely unattended while Southern Cameroonian politicians, political organisations and advocates of competing political outcomes have expended considerable energy on internal disagreements and contests for political relevance.
A people’s conference should help foster unity of purpose without demanding uniformity of political thought. We do not have to agree on every aspect of our political destination to agree on the need to protect our people, rebuild our communities and prepare for a peaceful future.
Recalibration must involve the people
Mr. Yerima rightly acknowledges the institutional defects, leadership failures, strategic miscalculations and missed opportunities that have characterised our liberation struggle. He also recognises the need for strategic recalibration.
But who should undertake this recalibration? Can the leaders of political movements be expected to examine their own shortcomings, determine their responsibility and prescribe corrective measures without meaningful participation from the people who have borne the consequences of their decisions?
The people of Southern Cameroons are not spectators in a liberation struggle being conducted on their behalf. They are its principal stakeholders. They have lost loved ones, abandoned homes, suffered displacement, endured economic hardship and watched their communities deteriorate. They have every right to participate in examining what has happened and determining what should happen next.
It would be rather curious to acknowledge institutional failures and then reserve the exercise of correcting them exclusively for the institutions and personalities associated with those failures.
Strategic recalibration cannot simply mean another gathering of familiar political actors exchanging familiar positions, issuing another communiqué and returning to the same institutional arrangements. The people must have an opportunity to question, assess, recommend and participate in shaping the way forward.
The intelligentsia must return to the table
Another constituency whose participation deserves particular attention is the intelligentsia. The intellectual and professional community played an important role in laying the foundations for the mass mobilisation of 2016. Lawyers, university scholars, teachers, researchers, trade unionists and other professionals helped articulate grievances, organise collective action and provide intellectual direction to the movement.
Over time, however, this constituency was progressively marginalised. The liberation struggle increasingly became entangled in contests of personalities, competing egos, factional interests and political rivalries. Intellectual discipline and professional refinement gradually gave way to an environment in which dissent was too often treated as disloyalty and critical examination as opposition.
The consequences have been painful. Our civilians and those involved in the armed resistance have borne immeasurable suffering, while opportunities for constructive political engagement have repeatedly been lost.
Although some intellectuals also became associated with practices that contributed to this unfortunate history, the majority did not embrace the excesses that increasingly characterised the political environment. Many withdrew, disillusioned by a process that offered little room for independent thought, professional judgement and constructive disagreement.
TPCC should therefore provide an opportunity to bring this estranged constituency back to the table. We need historians, constitutional lawyers, political scientists, economists, psychologists, sociologists, diplomats, development specialists and other professionals to contribute their expertise to examining the conflict, its consequences and the options available for a peaceful and sustainable future.
A struggle cannot continually lament the absence of strategic thinking while remaining suspicious of the very people whose intellectual contributions could help restore it.
Some mistakes were not inevitable
Mr. Yerima regrets the mistakes, missed opportunities and strategic setbacks that have characterised the struggle. This acknowledgement deserves further reflection because not all our mistakes were unavoidable.
Some were the consequences of institutional decisions imposed through decrees, directives and unilateral pronouncements. Others emerged from ordinary human weaknesses such as pride, anger, personal ambition and disruptive competition. More troublingly, some decisions that subsequently proved damaging had been questioned or cautioned against by people who understood their likely consequences, yet those warnings were disregarded.
We should therefore be careful not to romanticise every failure as an unfortunate mistake or an unavoidable consequence of a difficult liberation struggle. There is a difference between an honest error of judgement and a decision taken in disregard of reasonable warnings.
A genuine process of recalibration must be willing to examine these distinctions. It must provide room for accountability, institutional learning and the restoration of a culture in which decisions are subjected to reasoned scrutiny before they are imposed on an entire people.
Otherwise, we risk giving new names to old practices and presenting recycled mistakes as renewed strategic thinking.
Consultation is not a foreign concept
It is somewhat remarkable that a people’s conference should generate apprehension among a population whose political aspirations have historically been articulated through collective consultation. Perhaps we have become so accustomed to leadership by decree, fiat, monologue and communiqué that genuine consultation now seems like an unfamiliar political experiment. We have witnessed enough unilateral pronouncements and institutional directives to appreciate the limitations of making decisions without meaningful participation from the people affected by them.
Consultation should not be mistaken for weakness, indecision or an abandonment of political conviction. Neither should it be interpreted as an attempt to surrender the people’s aspirations to a gathering of individuals.
The conveners are not the owners of TPCC. The citizens of the former British Southern Cameroons are its principal stakeholders. The conveners have an important responsibility to facilitate the process, but the legitimacy and usefulness of the conference must ultimately derive from the participation and confidence of the people.
The conference must not become the private property of its organisers, just as the liberation struggle must not become the exclusive preserve of political organisations, individual leaders or competing advocacy groups. Either attempt is bound to crash. A people’s conference belongs to the people.
To whom will the conference report?
Mr. Yerima raises an important question when he asks who will receive the findings of TPCC, what will be reported and who will act upon them. This is a legitimate institutional concern and deserves a satisfactory response.
However, the absence of an immediately identified recipient should not be sufficient reason to question the necessity of the consultation itself. The first responsibility of a people’s conference is to the people. Its findings should be communicated transparently to the constituencies whose participation and experiences informed its deliberations.
Its recommendations should also provide a basis for identifying appropriate mechanisms through which agreed positions can be pursued and communicated to relevant political, professional, civil society and diplomatic stakeholders.
Indeed, determining how the people’s collective views should be represented, communicated and acted upon is itself one of the matters that consultation ought to address.
We cannot indefinitely postpone the creation of those structures while waiting for someone else to tell us which structures we need.
An invitation to participate, not surrender one’s convictions
Participation in TPCC does not necessarily amount to endorsing federalism, abandoning independence or accepting any predetermined political settlement. The conference can accommodate different political perspectives without requiring participants to surrender their convictions.
Those who favour complete independence should be able to articulate their position. Those who hold different views should equally have the opportunity to explain their perspectives. The objective is not to compel everyone to adopt the same political conclusion but to identify areas where collective action and common understanding are possible.
Those who remain concerned about the intentions, credibility or possible direction of TPCC should articulate their reservations. Those who have questions about representation, procedure, accountability or the status of its findings should raise them publicly. Those who are cautious may seek clarification before participating.
But disagreement should not automatically translate into obstruction, and suspicion should not become a licence to undermine an initiative before its possibilities have been fully examined.
If there are weaknesses in the proposed process, let us identify them and recommend improvements. If there are questions requiring clarification, let us ask them. If there are alternative proposals, let us put them forward.
We have spent too much time arguing about who should lead the conversation and too little time deciding what the conversation should accomplish.
Conclusion
Let the people speak!
Mr. Yerima insists that the destination remains a free Ambazonia. That is his declared political conviction, and he is entitled to articulate it. But a destination alone does not constitute a strategy, just as repeating a political objective does not answer the many questions arising from its pursuit.
TPCC offers an opportunity to bring together a divided people, restore the participation of estranged intellectuals and professionals, examine the consequences of the conflict and collectively prepare for the future.
We should neither romanticise the conference nor prejudge its outcome. We should engage with it, question it, improve it and hold its organisers accountable.
Let us not destroy the table simply because we have not agreed on who should sit where or what the final communiqué should contain. Our people have suffered enough from decisions made without them. They deserve an opportunity to participate in determining what comes next.
The conveners do not own the conference. The political organisations do not own the liberation struggle. And no individual, however distinguished his position or history, has an exclusive claim to speak for the people.
Let the conference proceed. Let the people speak. Our differences about the destination should not prevent us from preparing the journey together.
